Cycle News is a weekly magazine that covers all aspects of motorcycling including Supercross, Motocross and MotoGP as well as new motorcycles
Issue link: https://magazine.cyclenews.com/i/127940
decided to try to resolve these drawbacks by taking the basic components of a rotary disc-induction two-stroke engine and grafting them on to a fourstroke motor to produce the best of both worlds. After a great deal of work and experimentation since building my first six-stroke prototype in 1990, I truly believe we've refined the concept, proved its reliability and established its worth, so now we have it fully patented - even in the United States - and ready for commercial use in the variety of applications it obviously lends itself to, including motorcycles, stationary engine and, because of the exceptional torque at low rpm, propeller-aircraft engines." Gosh - could this bush-engineered Better Way perhaps be the mechanical equivalent of a Bimota Tesi or Saxon Saxtrack/BMW Telelever alternative chassis concept for volume production? . Well, let's see what it consists of: Below the cylinder-head gasket, everything is conventional, so one advantage is U,at the Beare concept can be transplanted onto existing engines without any need for redesigning or retooling the bottom end, thus reducing startup and manufacturing costs. But above there, he's thrown away the cylinder head, complete with poppet valves. (What, no desmodromics on the Beare Ducati?! Well, there are - sort of. Wait and see.) To replace the camshaft and associated valves, Beare has retained the cam drivebelt and fitted an ultrashort-stroke upper crankshaft complete with piston, which the belt drives at half engine -speed, just as it previously drove the camshaft. This piston slides up and down in a sleeve, past inlet and exhaust ports se't into the cylinder wall, very much as on a two-stroke; These are all exposed during both inlet and exhaust strokes. Continuing the two-stroke analogy, the two 35mm Mikuni CV carbs mounted on each cylinder of fue Ducatibased V-twin feed mixture into it via a reed-valve block, thus preventing exhaust gases exiting through the inlet port. At the other end of the upper crankshaft is a two-stroke-type rotary disc valve that regulates the exhaust timing, cutting off the exhaust flow at the appropriate time to stop the gases from returning to the cylinder, fuus creating subatmospheric pressure during the inlet cycle. This being its only function, the rotary valve has only a light· load on it, reducing lubrication and sealing problems - though the close tolerances entailed did lead to a warping problem with the stainless-steel disc Malcolm used on his first six-stroke design, based on a Honda XL125. Replacing this with a cast-iron one on his next version, based on a Yamaha XT500, cured this problem at the expense of unnecessary extra weight, but the Ducati uses hardened, anodized aluminum discs, which work well. During the compression and expansion strokes, the upper piston seals off both ports, leaving the pressure contained between the two pistons, with the lower one a conventional flat-top threering design, while the conical upper one (so shaped to aid gas flow during both inlet and exhaust cycles, by~uiding it toward the ports) has two rings - one compression, one oil. In the combustion phase, twin sparkplugs provide ignition using the stock Ducati CDI and a pair of Harley coils - one per cylinder - and not only does the engine run on gasoline. alone (no need to add oil, because all required surfaces are positively lubricated, in spite of the application of twostroke technology), it's also happy on. low-octane unIeadeQ fuel. Obviously, there are no valve seats to suffer from a lack of lead, and Malcolm says the compression ratio can be increased significantly from the Ducati motor's 10.6:1 quite safely because of the lack of hotspots, without problems with detonation. Okay, so the Beare six~stroke has impeccable green credentials - but tbat just gives a hint at the commercial and technical advantages. Malcolm seems justified in claiming for his design. The obvious benefit in strict engineering terms is that by -eliminating poppet val ves on a four-stroke, you also remove any chance of valve float arrd thus of bending them (more cost-effective tban desmodromic valves, and less inertia, too), which in turn implies a far higher safe rev limit for the six-stroke - 28,000 rpm in theory, given the ha1f enginespeed operation"of the upper crankshaft, and the tact that GP reed-valve twostrokes peak at 14,000 rpm. But Malcolm Beare says fue rev limit, as on such two-strokes, depends only on what the main (conventional) crankshaft is able to bear - he's arbitrarily limited the Ducati-based 65-V2 to 9000 rpm for fuat reason, at which point he says 86 bhp is delivered at the rear wheel, according to computer predictions fuere aren't too many Dynojet rigs out in the Australian outback! Comparisons are hard to make, because of the difficulty of determining the exact cubic capacity of the 6S-V2's six-~troke engine. What began as an elderly Pantah V-twin now has a total 744cc of compression/expansion volume, and 602cc of inlet/exhaust volume, and instead of absorbing about 10 percent of engine power in driving the camshafts, the cambelts now deliver about 9 percent net power back to the main crankshaft after combustion, via the upper, conical porting piston. (See desmo power!) But if you figure. that a '97-model Ducati 90055 delivers 73 bhp at the rear wheel in stock form, that's quite an impressive claimed power increase. But there are other, much more significant apparent spinoff benefits from the Beare design. (Above left) Two carburetors for each cylinder are used on the plston-port-and-discvalve cylinder heads. The basis for the powerplant Is a Ducati. twin. (Above) The parts that make the difference: The regular Ducati piston (bottom) has a smaller piston locatec:! directly opposite - this is the twostroke part, with the disc valve (left) and reed valves (right), that controls the induction of the air·fuel mixture, by covering and uncovering ports. Twin plugs fire the mixture using the Ducati COl and Harley coils. The exhaust has a very unusual sound. (Right) The valve gear is run at half the crankshaft speed, just as on a normal Ducati. Without the threat of valve float to limit revs, the bottom end becomes the limiting factor in attainable engine speed. The first of these is fuel economy: Malcolm Beare claims his engine is 35 pertent more economical at low revs/ throttle openings than an equivalent conventional engine, and 13 percent less thirsty at high rpm/full throttle. By definition, therefore, there are reduced hydrocarbon emissions, because you're using less fuel to achieve the same performance. Next, there's improved torque at lower revs. On both his Yamaha- and Ducati-based prototypes, Beare discovered fue six-stroke version produced the same torque as the four-stroke conventional motor 1000 rpm lower down the rev scale, as well as producing exponentially more torque as revs rose. Bu t in a commercial application, perhaps th.e most attractive benefit is the reduced number of moving parts, compared to a four-stroke design - not as few as a twostroke, but what you appear to be get. ting here is improved performance and torque, coupled with the inherent advantages of a four-stroke, on the cheap. Because those fewer moving parts mean reduced manufacturing costs and - allied with the fact that the upper twostroke piston is driven at half engine speed, and so should have twice the engine life of the lower four-stroke one reduced maintenance and componentreplacement costs. Sounds promising. It was time to find out for myself, so ~alcolm Beare fired up the 6S-V2 to give me a hands-on impression of bush' engineering at its best. Okay - while the Beare V-twin may appear a little rough on the edges, remember that it's obviously been built to a budget as well as acting as a rolling testbed for continuous modification, so let's ignore the looks and worry about the sizzle. To start with, it has an absolutely unique engine sound, like nofuing else I've ever heard in my life - not even a Norton rotary racer. You can clearly hear the ring-ding two-stroke signature tune above fue trademark four-stroke Vtwin boom from the twin megaphone exhausts. Two engines in one - uncanny. In fact, fue engine seems very loud, but that's apparently only because the megaphones of this BEARS racer are unsilenced. But, Malcolm says, there's actually much-reduced mechanical engine noise from the engine, because of fue fewer moving parts. "We silenced the exhaust on the XT500 Yamaha-based bike considerably," he says, "and the result was, you could hardly hear the engine running. Without any tappet noise, it's remarkably silent - and that's in spite of being air-cooled, as all my prototypes have been. Heat dissipation is not a problem, so while it'd be easy to water-cool the engine by drowning the combustion chamber, there's honestly no need for tbe extra complication on grounds of noise or thermal efficiency. But one area I haven't done any work on is exhaust development - the six-stroke format would certainly lend itself to expansionchamber exhaust technology borrowed from performance two-strokes." IX) 0\ 0\ ...... 0\' N ....... .I-< "" 0.. -< 33

