Cycle News is a weekly magazine that covers all aspects of motorcycling including Supercross, Motocross and MotoGP as well as new motorcycles
Issue link: https://magazine.cyclenews.com/i/127864
IN THE PADDOCK
BYMICHAE C TT
LS O
lav out is not very
D
o r th re e
yea rs a go , peoa me n able to Big
ple w ere s ta r tBang firing order,
ing 10 talk about the
th o u gh th e y d id
try ve r y h ard ,
Y-four 500cc G rand
along wi th a m asPri x facto ry bikes as
"cl u msy dinosaurs:'
s ive ba la nce shaf t.
No r did they ever
Their time was over,
wi th V-tw i ns se t to
get thei r exha us t
push l he m hard,
va lves
p ower
working righ t. The
und e r the c u r re n t
b ike rem a in ed a
fa vo ra b le weight
rules - a nd just wait
handfu l throu ghuntil the th ree-cylin o ut it s fi rs t two
d er bik es ge t going .
years, an d ha d susAft er a co up le o f
pect reli ab ility to
boot.
years of serio us skirmishing, it must be Ap rilla 's Y-twln (19) batt les with Honda's v -tcur (7). Honda's Y-tw in (18) an d Vamat'a's YOnce
aga in ,
sa id that the Vvfou rs l our (5). Despite the co mpetition l rom twin s and trip les , the Y-l our is still king .
word is that develo p me n t will cease
have put up a pretty
on the Elf 500 a lso
convincing fi ght,
and ano ther private team will be giv en
sibility of getting the ax . Hav ing g row n
wh ile after just one yea r, the th ree-cylinbit by bit to almos t 480cc lrom the origithe task - if one can be found tha t is prede r op tion - Kenny Roberts' Mod en as has fallen short of expec tations.
pared to should er this heavy burden.
nal 430cc, an d ha ving deli vered Doriano
There is a twi n tha t has put up a worRomboni to the fron t row on four occaThere are very di fferen t rea sons for
sions, and" to the rostru m (at Assen) for
th e fact tha t Kenny Rob erts 's cu stom th y fight - H o n d a ' s ow n factory
the first time in four years of tryi ng, the
m ad e three -cy linder Mode nas did not
mach ine, ri d de n to a bes t of second
pretty ta nd em -tw in (two' cra nkshaft s)
place tw u yea rs in a row by Tadayuki
com e within sp itting distance of targets
"s u per-Zfifl" has su cceeded in every
Okada and then Takuma Aoki - and this
and aspirations, cri p pled often as not by
tech nical a im ex cept one: The damn
gives s treng th to the "d inosa u r" faction.
it s own technical adventures . The
The Honda NSR-Y is th e only non Ything lacks acceleration, so even when
design really was relatively radical in
Romboni did start from th e front row,
three particular regards:
fou r to have had development budget
and resources in the same league as the
he was usua lly last or close to last by the
• Th e Y-three engin e adopted a
established V-fours. Even then, this is
time the rest of th em had rea ched th e
strange, lopsided architectu re, wit h two
cy lind ers sharing o ne crankcase, and a
only a fraction of the lotal amou n t spent
first comer.
on all the Japanese V-fours.
No fina l decision had been made, but
sin gleton on the side.
• With no room within the vee for
The matter is not settled yet - though
it seemed likely tha t the Aprilia factory
Mil pass the wh ole ca boodle on to a prico nve ntiona l carburetors, and to reduce
at the privateer level , onl y o ne was left
vate team next yea r, a n d w a sh their
size, the team ad opted their own "KR"
of the mainstay V-Iour ROC- and Harris-Yarnahas, with everybody else havha nds of an at least partially su ccessful
electronic carbureto rs, p ressure-fed by
ing switched to the Honda Y-twins,
exercise.
pump.
The ot her European effort wa h the Elf
But the revolution is not only about
• A small frontal area and good aerop roviding an alternative to V-fours. The
d ynam ic penetration carne from the
500, which challenged the Japa nese a t
thei r own game; a V-jou r, it did things
major thrust is to rival the Japanese faccompact design, with ai r d ucte d to a
in rat her different ways from the estabtories themselves, with a direct attack on
rear-mounted radiator be neath the seat.
lishment. The Elf is powered by the oneFor an all-new design by an all-new
wha t Kenny Roberts contemptuously
refers to as "sticker bikes - they're delivti m e SwissAuto engine that achieved
team - the ca r -ra cing people at Tom
success in sideca rs, a nd its technical
Walkinshaw Racing - lhe Modenas' first
ered, you p ut your stickers on, and go
quirk is that each cylinder pair shares a
year wa s far from shabby. By compariracing."
son, Ho nda's first yea r with the ir Y·four
commo n cra nkcase, m a king two instead
H ere we find the other side of the
of the usual four. The gain comes in dissaw it break w heels and cras h, and to be
coin - or maybe that should be "lack 01
pensing wi th main bearings, and red ucso in tractable in m a n y aspects th a t it
coin." The end of the I997 season finds
was dumped in favor of the old V-three
the challengers in se rious d isa rra y.
ing fric tio n, And the Elf certainly d id
The original alternative, and the firs t
have p lenty of horse po wer. The difficulby a desperate Fredd ie Spencer well
before the end of the season. Bu t Robe rts
V-rw in, the Aprilia, faces a distinct pusty came in trying to ma ke it rid able. The
puts his finger on one particula r we ak ness tha t d ogged the p ro je thro ughout:
ct
It wa s that old enemy of many mo torcycles - vibra tion.
"The cra nks haft people told us they
co u ld make us th e cra nks th at would
run smooth - but they could n' t d eliver."
Vibration ca used fuel-frot hing p roblems
that made the performance o f the wac ky
ca rbs infu r ia ti ng ly e rra tic . Vibratio n
con trib uted to coo ling problems, where
cavi ta tion and poor pumping circulation
mea nt it wa s always ru n ning hot. Vibratio n also ca u sed problems fam ilia r to
anyo ne wh o has ridd en a '60s Triumph
o r Norton - b reakages from cranks hafts
to foo tpegs, cha fed wires, lea ks, electrical problems, and a level of riding discomfo rt that mak es it a hu ge pleasure to
swi tch the en gine off.
It was almost incidental that. when
they put the bik e in a wind tunnel mid season, the aerodynamics that looked
good on paper turned out to be deeply
flawed .
W hat the Modenas ne ed s , .ays
Roberts, is an engine redesign. The next
V-three would put a m ain cra n ks ha ft
bearing in th e co m m o n c ra n kca s e,
where th ere now is n one, and would
probably als o have a bal ance shaft, to
make damn, dam n sur e to kill the vib ration so they can get on with developing
the res t 01 the bike.
But th is alternati ve is a lso in jeopardy. The Marlboro sponsors hip is considered almos t cer ta in to go, at least
partly because it ' s just not enough to
provid e for Roberts' plans. "W e need
TI
more mon e y, more manpower, and
more co m m itmen t than in the first
year," says Roberts, who is thought to
be seeking ba cking from Petronas in
Malaysia, home of Mod enas themselves.
Modenas' only other modelis a stepthrough scoot er.
In th e middle 01 all this , however, the
Malaysian economy ran into a major
collapse - leaving the Grand Prix Modems out on a limb.
"Next yea r, if we can 't do it properly ,
with a ll the backing we need, the n we
won't do it all ," concluded Roberts. O ne
must hope it was not a sell-fulfilling
prophecy.
'"
LOOKING BACK...
30 Y AR
E SAGO..,
OVEMBE 6,1967
R1
N
20 Y
EARSA
GO...
NOVEMBER 9, 1977
illed as the Gi ant Roa d
Ri d er Is s u e , CN ~44
also featured typ os ,
among other things, on its
cover . The issue was still
called number 43 and was
dated Nove m ber 9, 1967.
You- k now-w hat happens,
but a t least the issue lived
up to its cover lines, as
there was extensive coverage of the Death Valley To ur an d th e EI To ur
Grand e to Ensenad a, Mexico... Dan Haaby (BSA) and
Sammy Tanner